The impact of calibration conditions on the transferability of conceptual hydrological models under stationary and nonstationary climatic conditions

Abstract

Changing climatic conditions have changed the stationary rainfall-runoff relationships in many basins. In this context, the value of the model parameters will depend more on the selection of the calibration period, which directly affects the accuracy of runoff forecasting. However, systematic exploration and testing of the impact of calibration conditions on the transferability of hydrological models under stationary and nonstationary climatic conditions require more effort. The present study investigates the impact of four calibration conditions on model transferability, including the length of the calibration period, the length of the interval between the calibration and transfer periods, the difference in climate conditions as measured by the total rainfall amount between the calibration and transfer periods, and the difference in the similarity of rainfall processes between the calibration and transfer periods. Two catchments with stationary and nonstationary climatic conditions, and five models, including XAJ, HBV, IHACRES, SIMHYD and GR4J, are used in this study. The results show that (1) a longer calibration period is required for catchments with nonstationary rainfall-runoff relationships to achieve stable simulations; (2) with the increase in the length of the interval between the calibration and transfer periods, the transferability of the model decreases gradually, and the degree of reduction is greater for catchments with nonstationary climatic conditions and rainfall-runoff relationships; and (3) when forecasting future runoff under nonstationary rainfall-runoff relationships, the closeness of the total rainfall amount between the calibration and transfer periods is more important than the similarity in rainfall series between the calibration and transfer periods. This study provides insight into the impact of calibration conditions on the transferability of hydrological models in the context of climate change.